Hard vs. Soft Enamel Pins: Which is Right for Your Business?

In today’s competitive business landscape, custom enamel pins are powerful branding tools that provide measurable value.
Whether you’re looking to recognize top employees, express appreciation to loyal clients, or enhance your brand’s visibility at events, enamel pins custom solutions offer an impactful option.

But one key decision often confuses businesses:
👉 Should you choose hard enamel pins or soft enamel pins?

Hard Enamel vs Soft Enamel Pins comparison, showcasing the difference between a smooth, recessed surface on a light grey background.

This guide breaks down the differences, use cases, and design tips—so your company can choose with confidence.

What Are Enamel Pins?

Definition

An enamel pin is a small, customizable metal badge filled with colorful enamel. Companies can choose size, shape, finish, and plating, making them versatile for recognition programs, promotions, or client gifts.

Popular types include:

  • Soft enamel lapel pins → textured, colorful, and affordable.
  • Hard enamel lapel pins → smooth, polished, and premium-looking.

How They’re Made

Manufacturing process of Enamel pins showing the polishing and grinding stage to achieve a perfectly smooth, flat surface.

The production steps are similar, but the finish differs:

  • Hard Enamel Pins → baked at high heat, then polished flat for a glossy, jewelry-like surface.
  • Soft Enamel Pins → air-dried, leaving raised borders and recessed enamel for a textured effect.

👉 Pin backs also matter. Businesses can choose enamel pin backs like butterfly clutches, rubber clutches, or magnets for secure wear.

Why Businesses Use Enamel Pins

Enamel pins are more than decorative—they’re business assets:

📈 Brand Visibility – Showcase your logo at trade shows, product launches, and marketing campaigns.
🏅 Employee Recognition – Celebrate years of service or achievements with custom hard enamel pins.
🎁 Corporate Gifts – Strengthen client relationships with polished, professional pins.
🏆 Fundraising & Awareness – Nonprofits often distribute soft enamel pins to boost visibility and raise support.

💡 Case Example: A retail chain launched limited-edition custom soft enamel pins during the holiday season. The pins sold out in two weeks, driving both sales and brand awareness.

Hard Enamel Pins: The Premium Choice

Process

Created by baking enamel at high heat and polishing it flush with the metal, producing a smooth, glossy surface.

Advantages for Businesses

🔒 Durability – Scratch-resistant and long-lasting.
✨ Professional Appearance – Conveys prestige and high value.
🎨 Color Stability – Colors retain vibrancy over time.

Corporate executive wearing a premium Hard Enamel pin on a suit lapel during a formal award ceremony.

Drawbacks

💰 Higher production cost per unit.
⚠️ Fine details may blur after polishing.

Best Uses

  • Financial institutions → hard enamel lapel pins for long-service awards.
  • Law firms → custom hard enamel pins as premium client loyalty gifts.

Design Tips

✔ Use bold, clean logos.
✔ Stick to solid brand colors.
✔ Pair with gold or silver plating for a luxury feel.

Soft Enamel Pins: Affordable Creativity

Process

Air-dried enamel fills recessed areas, leaving raised metal borders for texture and depth.

Advantages for Businesses

💵 Cost-Effective – Budget-friendly, great for bulk orders.
🎨 Creative Freedom – Allows intricate, colorful artwork.
🌟 Approachable Style – Fun and engaging look.

Diverse team members wearing colorful Soft Enamel pins on backpacks and denim jackets in a casual, collaborative office setting

Drawbacks

⚠️ More prone to scratches.
🎯 Informal style, not ideal for executive recognition.

Best Uses

  • Retail chains → seasonal soft enamel lapel pins for promotions.
  • Nonprofits → soft enamel pins at charity events for awareness.

Design Tips

✔ Bold outlines and bright colors work best.
✔ Add epoxy coating for protection.
✔ Experiment with creative shapes or seasonal themes.

Hard vs. Soft Enamel Pins: Business Comparison

Feature Hard Enamel Pins Soft Enamel Pins Business Value
Appearance Smooth, polished, jewelry-like finish Textured surface with raised borders Prestige vs Creativity
Durability Scratch-resistant, long-lasting Durable but more prone to scratches Longevity vs Flexibility
Cost Higher per-unit price Budget-friendly, ideal for bulk orders Premium look vs Cost efficiency
Best For Recognition awards, executive gifts Event giveaways, marketing campaigns Loyalty vs Brand Reach
Design Fit Clean logos, solid colors Detailed, colorful artwork Professional Image vs Creative Engagement

👉 Key Takeaway:

  • Hard enamel pin = prestige, loyalty, and recognition.
  • Soft enamel pin = reach, creativity, and affordability.

How to Choose the Right Enamel Pin for Your Business

1️⃣ Define Your Purpose

  • Hard Enamel → recognition programs, executive gifts, high-value branding.
  • Soft Enamel → events, employee engagement, large-scale giveaways.

2️⃣ Consider Budget & Timeline

  • Hard Enamel → higher price, suited for smaller premium orders.
  • Soft Enamel → more affordable, ideal for high-volume distribution.

⏱ Production Time Reference

  • Rush Orders → 1–3 days production + 3–5 days shipping = 5–7 days total
  • Normal Orders → 5–7 days production + 3–5 days shipping = 7–15 days total

3️⃣ Evaluate Design

  • Hard Enamel → best for bold logos, solid colors, professional image.
  • Soft Enamel → great for detailed, colorful, creative designs.

💡 Think of pins as an extension of your brand.
If you want stability and prestige → choose hard enamel.
If you value reach and engagement → choose soft enamel.

FAQ

Q: What is soft enamel?

A: Soft enamel pins use recessed paint with raised borders, creating a colorful, textured finish.

Q: How are enamel pins made?

A: The process includes:

  1. Designing artwork
  2. Creating a mold
  3. Stamping or casting metal
  4. Electroplating with gold, silver, or nickel
  5. Filling with enamel paint
  6. Baking (hard) or air-drying (soft)
  7. Adding enamel pin backs (butterfly clutch, rubber clutch, or magnetic)

Q: How long does production take?

A: Timelines vary by service method:

  • Rush Orders → 5–7 days total (production + shipping).
  • Normal Orders → 7–15 days total.

Q: How to design enamel pins?

A: Keep logos bold and simple, match pin type to purpose, and choose plating that aligns with your brand.

Q: Which enamel pin is best for corporate branding?

  • Hard enamel pin → prestige, durability, loyalty.
  • Soft enamel pin → reach, creativity, affordability.

Conclusion

Collection of custom Hard Enamel and Soft Enamel pin samples, displaying a variety of designs, shapes, and color finishes

Both hard enamel pins and soft enamel pins are powerful branding tools.

  • Hard enamel = polished, durable, and perfect for recognition and premium gifts.
  • Soft enamel = colorful, versatile, and budget-friendly for campaigns and events.

👉 The best choice depends on your company’s goals, budget, and timeline.
By aligning enamel type with your branding strategy, you create pins that not only look great but also leave a lasting impression.

✅ Ready to elevate your branding?
Whether you need custom soft enamel pins for campaigns or custom hard enamel pins for executive awards, Yearpins® delivers quality, fast turnaround, and bulk discounts.

✨Related Articles✨

Unique Lapel Pin Ideas for Personalized Gifts and Mementos

What to do with enamel pins

How to Create a Unique Custom Lapel Pin: A Step-by-Step Guide

How to Create Enamel Pins

Soft Enamel VS Hard Enamel

The secret of badge powdering process is here

 

Back to blog